In terms of
voice between the profiles of Mr. Rogers and Roger Ebert the one that formed a
stronger connection to me was that of Mr. Rogers. Tom Junod constructs a voice
here that allows the reader to become very personally involved with his
narrative. Instead of simply giving us a story about the experience he had with
Mr. Rogers he brings it home by reflecting on how it made him feel. The voice
comes off as someone who has come to terms with their own insecurities and is
willing to open their mind to the reader like a book. The beginning story of
Old Rabbit captivates the reader into wanting to find out exactly what this has
to do with Mr. Rogers. These personal touches cause the reader to
find a slight investment in the story that they might not have had otherwise. Once
he gets into the actual profiling he does a good job of structuring the story
in such a way that continues to bring Old Rabbit in at periodic times to help
pull the reader along. That’s not to say that a day in the life of Mr. Roger’s
is boring. In fact, once Tom begins relating Mr. Rogers’ routine and
emphasizing a slow, gentle tone to emulate Mr. Rogers the voice finds a new way
to captivate the reader. It’s very easy to slip into the narrative and begin to
feel that Mr. Roger’s voice is talking to you.
One
thing that the voice reveals about Mr. Roger’s is the amount of structure that
goes into his daily life. Tom uses structure in the essay to help reader’s
understand Mr. Rogers a bit better. This can be seen in the way that Tom allows
the sentences to become long, at one point an entire sentence becomes a single
paragraph, and the way that the sentences craft the story simply:
ONCE UPON A TIME, a long
time ago, a man took off his jacket and put on a sweater. Then he took off his
shoes and put on a pair of sneakers. His name was Fred Rogers. He was starting
a television program, aimed at children, called Mister Rogers'
Neighborhood. He had
been on television before, but only as the voices and movements of puppets, on
a program called The Children's
Corner. Now he was
stepping in front of the camera as Mister Rogers, and he wanted to do things
right, and whatever he did right, he wanted to repeat. And so, once upon a
time, Fred Rogers took off his jacket and put on a sweater his mother had made
him, a cardigan with a zipper.
The story begins with
once upon a time and then as he begins to tell the next part of it he repeats
that phrase. In this way he helps the reader to discover more about Mr. Roger’s
personality. The voice and the content here go hand in hand to make it clear
exactly what is happening. Every day Mr. Rogers goes through the same tasks in
a manner that could in a way be described as obsessive. The words here seem
very precise and particular so they are in fitting with that manner. They also
seem as if they are the beginning to a children’s story, something spoken to a
child before they begin to fall asleep. The profile does a good job of using
voice to relate who Mr. Rogers is. It even sticks to this structure when in the end we are gifted with the knowledge of Tom's great revelation with Mr. Rogers. Here repetition is used in the form of the unfolding of the Old Rabbit narrative that we have received throughout the profile.
I totally agree! The personal element and how the author publicly develops personally because of Mister Rogers over the course of the profile is deeply intimate and revealing; I feel that getting to fully understand Mister Rogers requires the reader to witness the compelling effects he has on others. The voice the author employed for Mister Rogers' profile was my favorite for this reason as well. (:
ReplyDelete